Leadership
Pushed out of Uber, Travis Kalanick wrote rules for surviving a coup. Half are red flags
On 9 November, Uber co-founder Travis Kalanick posted twelve rules for a leader under attack. The rules about handling your own fear match what psychologists have measured. Several rules about cutting people off match a list of warning signs that a psychologist drew up in 1972. The last rule depends on how a messaging app protects its chats.
- The rules about your own mind have research behind them. People overestimate how much bad news will hurt. In one 1989 study, imagining that an outcome had already happened made people better at explaining it.
- Three rules match groupthink’s warning signs. Irving Janis listed pressure on dissenters framed as disloyalty, and contempt for opponents, among the signs that a group is heading for a bad decision.
- Loyalty can cost competence. In Georgy Egorov and Konstantin Sonin’s model of rulers who fear betrayal, insecure rulers end up “hiring mediocre but loyal subordinates.”
- Telegram holds the keys to ordinary chats. By Telegram’s own account, it encrypts end to end only the secret chats a user opens on purpose.
On 9 November 2026, Travis Kalanick posted a list on X titled “Practical principles to counter a modern-day coup/psyop/struggle session.” It has twelve rules, and he asked readers to “send along to someone you know who may benefit.” The post drew more than 800,000 views.
Kalanick co-founded Uber and ran it until June 2017. That year began with a blog post by former Uber engineer Susan Fowler, who wrote that when she reported sexual harassment, both “HR and upper management” let the man off with a warning. An outside investigation of Uber’s workplace followed. In June, Kalanick resigned after five major investors, including the venture firm Benchmark, demanded it in a letter. He now runs Atoms, the company that owns CloudKitchens. The new post does not say what prompted it.
The title borrows from politics and war. A coup is a sudden, illegal seizure of power. A psyop, short for psychological operation, is a military campaign of messages meant to change how a target audience feels and acts. A struggle session was a “form of public humiliation and torture” in Mao’s China, at its peak during the Cultural Revolution of 1966 to 1976.
The twelve rules sort by what they are about
Some of the rules are about the leader’s own state of mind. Most are about the people around the leader. One is about software. Nobody has tested the list as a whole, so Figure 1 checks each rule against the closest published research.
Press a card to see what the research says.
Three rules have research behind them and six match warning signs. Two are untested, and one depends on a fact about software.
Bad news hurts less than people expect
Rule 3, “nothing is as bad as it seems,” has the best evidence behind it. In a study published in 1998, the psychologist Daniel Gilbert and four colleagues asked assistant professors at the University of Texas at Austin how happy they would be after a tenure decision. Tenure is a permanent job, and being denied it usually means leaving. They also asked former assistant professors, who had already been granted or denied tenure, how happy they actually were.
On a scale from 1 (not happy) to 7 (very happy), how happy were people in the five years after being denied tenure?
People who had been denied tenure reported 4.71. The assistant professors had predicted 3.42 for themselves.
The authors blamed what they called immune neglect, people’s failure to account for how much their own minds soften a blow. The same pattern turned up in the paper’s other studies, including breakups and lost elections.
Two other rules about the leader’s own head have support. Rule 10 describes what the psychologist Gary Klein calls a premortem, imagining that a plan has already failed and asking why. Klein cites a 1989 study finding that imagining an outcome had already happened “increases the ability to correctly identify reasons for future outcomes by 30%.” That figure comes from a single study. Rule 8 recommends meditation. A 2014 review of 47 trials with 3,515 participants found moderate evidence that mindfulness programs ease anxiety and depression. The effect sizes were 0.38 for anxiety and 0.30 for depression. People in the programs ended up about a third of a standard deviation, the usual spread of scores, better off than people in comparison groups.
The rules about loyalty read like a list of warning signs
Most of the list is about other people, and here the research points the other way. In 1972 the psychologist Irving Janis described groupthink, the way a close-knit group can drift into a bad decision because nobody wants to break the consensus. He drew up eight warning signs. One is pressure on any member who questions the group, framed as disloyalty. Rule 6 says, “Do not hesitate in cutting off anyone you suspect of disloyalty.” Another is seeing opponents as weak or stupid, and rule 9 says, “Your enemies aren’t as smart or hard working as you.” A third is explaining away warnings, and rule 4 treats trouble as the work of enemies to be found and neutralized.
Three of Kalanick’s rules match warning signs on Janis’s 1972 list of how groups talk themselves into bad decisions.
Economists have modeled what loyalty tests do to a team. Georgy Egorov and Konstantin Sonin studied rulers who fear betrayal. Competent advisers are better at spotting plots, which also makes them more dangerous to the ruler, so “rulers, especially those which are weak and vulnerable, sacrifice the competence of their agents, hiring mediocre but loyal subordinates.” Figure 3 is a toy model of a related problem. It assumes that the advisers who report problems most often are the ones judged disloyal.
If the advisers who report problems most often are cut, how many problems still reach the leader?
With all 12 advisers, almost every problem reaches you.
Rule 5 calls those who turn on the leader “highly useful idiots,” meaning people who help a cause without knowing they are being used. The phrase is usually credited to Lenin, but that attribution “is not supported by any evidence.”
Telegram holds the keys to ordinary chats
Rule 12 depends on how Telegram protects messages, which can be checked. End-to-end encryption means that only the sender and the recipient hold the keys to read a message, so the company running the service cannot. Telegram’s FAQ says that “all messages in secret chats use end-to-end encryption,” while ordinary cloud chats “use client-server/server-client encryption and are stored encrypted in the Telegram Cloud.” That means messages are encrypted on the way to Telegram, and Telegram can decrypt them. Cloud chats are what users get unless they start a secret chat on purpose.
Who holds a key that can read the message?
In a cloud chat the message is encrypted on its way to Telegram and stored there, and Telegram holds the keys to it.
Telegram explains why it does not make every chat secret. Keeping cloud chats on its servers lets them be “immediately accessible from any of your devices – even if you lose your device altogether.”
Further reading
- Daniel Gilbert and colleagues, Immune neglect: A source of durability bias in affective forecasting (1998). The tenure study and five others.
- Gary Klein, Performing a Project Premortem (Harvard Business Review, 2007). How to run one.
- Georgy Egorov and Konstantin Sonin, Dictators and their Viziers (2011). The loyalty and competence trade-off.
- Groupthink. Janis’s eight warning signs and his case studies.
- Telegram FAQ. How cloud chats and secret chats differ.